Categorized | Commentary/Editorial

Governor Palin Gives the Media a History Lesson on Paul Revere’s Midnight Ride – UPDATED: The Governor Responds





The mark of any successful political venture by Governor Palin often results a misrepresentation of her words that only leaves the media with egg on their faces. Governor Palin’s bus tour has been successful in allowing her to highlight the greatness of the history of America, meet everyday Americans and fellow politicians, and share her policy stances on everything from fishing regulations in New Hampshire to ethanol subsidies to the debt ceiling. Such successes leaves the media grasping at proverbial bendy straws. Today’s news is no different. Poised with the opportunity to more appropriately address political stories essentially pre-written for them, such as abysmal jobs numbers under the Obama administration or the newest report that the federal government lends financial aid to the very same countries from whom they borrow , the media have chosen to focus more on their own historical ignorance by creating a story out of a non-story and  misportraying Governor Palin’s comments on Paul Revere yesterday:

“He who warned, uh, the British that they weren’t going to be taking away our arms uh by ringing those bells and making sure as he’s riding his horse through town to send those warning shots and bells that we were going to be secure and we were going to be free and we were going to be armed.”

Those quibbling with Governor Palin’s statements have their history incomplete. During Paul Revere’s ride he was stopped by British soldiers, which Revere recounts in a 1789 letter maintained by the Massachusetts Historical Society ,in his original language (emphasis mine):

I observed a Wood at a Small distance, & made for that. When I got there, out Started Six officers, on Horse back,and orderd me to dismount;-one of them, who appeared to have the command, examined me, where I came from,& what my Name Was? I told him. it was Revere, he asked if it was Paul? I told him yes He asked me if  I was an express? I answered in the afirmative. He demanded what time I left Boston? I told him; and  aded, that their troops had catched aground in passing the River, and that There would be five hundred Americans there in a short time, for I had alarmed the Country all the way up. He imediately rode towards those who stoppd us, when all five of them came down upon a full gallop; one of them, whom I afterwards found to be Major Mitchel, of the 5th Regiment, Clapped his pistol to my head, called me by name, & told me he was going to ask me some questions, & if I did not give him true answers, he would blow my brains out. He then asked me similar questions to those above. He then orderd me to mount my Horse, after searching me for arms.He then orderd them to advance, & to lead me in front. When we got to the Road, they
turned down towards Lexington. When we had got about one Mile, the Major Rode up to the officer that was leading me, & told him to give me to the Sergeant. As soon as he took me, the Major orderd him, if I attempted to run, or any body insulted them, to blow my brains out. We rode till we got near Lexington Meeting-house, when the Militia fired a Voley of Guns, which appeared to alarm them very much.

Upon being stopped, did Revere, in essence, warn the British soldiers of the colonists’ plans? Yes. The strawmen built by the media seems to almost indicate that Revere rode through the streets warning the British soldiers.  In actuality, simply put, Paul Revere told Regulars  of the colonists’ plans during his attempt to warn the colonists of the Regulars’ approach (Revere actually said, “the Regulars are coming!”. The colonist still viewed themselves as British subjects at the time and would not have said, “the British are coming”.)

Additionally, as the Paul Revere Heritage Project notes, Revere had reason for concern that the colonists’ arms would be taken away as they questioned the location of the militia’s ammunition (emphasis mine):

The Redcoats had set temporary roadblocks as a security measure and on their way to Concord they encountered British soldiers. Prescott managed to escape; Revere was captured and Dawes tried to run away but was arrested shortly thereafter. The British held Revere and interrogated him with a pistol on his chest. He was asked about the plans of the militia and where they kept their ammunition. When asked where the Patriots were hiding he told them the truth and replied that they had 500 militiamen in Concord protecting them and 1500 coming. As they rode towards Concord he was told that if he tried to escape he would be shot.

There were no claims by Governor Palin that Paul Revere’s ride had anything to do with the 2nd Amendment as some spuriously claim. She simply indicated the immediate concern of Revere and the colonists. It appears that the media once again fail to grasp the history of our Founding again. You may recall that the media were in an uproar when Governor Palin encouraged Tea Partiers to party like it’s 1773, and the media claimed she didn’t know her Revolutionary War  history. Oops. Governor Palin stated that this “One Nation” bus tour would, in part, draw attention to America’s founding and history. It looks like she is doing just that.

H/T Ian, Karen Allen, PalinSupporter

UPDATE: The Governor responds to Chris Wallace on Fox News Sunday



Tags: , , ,

Comment Policy: The Editors reserve the right to delete any comments which in their sole discretion are deemed false or misleading, profane, pornographic, defamatory, harassment, name calling, libelous, threatening, or otherwise inappropriate. Additionally, the Editors reserve the right to ban any registered poster who, in their sole discretion, violates the terms of use. Do not post any information about yourself reasonably construed as private or confidential. Conservatives4Palin and its contributors are not liable if users allow others to contact them offsite.

  • http://barbaricthoughts.com/ Kelsey

    Who? Romney who announced his 2012 run at Bittersweet Farm with “Scamman” on his podium? Ha!

  • Anonymous

    Who are you talking to???

  • Diana Moreno

    Sure, OK, what ever works for you all.  Too Funny–thanks for the laugh

  • JRNASH

    Why is it that liberals who write comments on the Internet always sound like little boys on the playground who are trying to say something that will shock everybody.  I think that is why you go to the dirty language so quickly.  You never attack Sarah Palin on the issues because you would lose the debate and you know it.  It seems to most conservatives that I know that people like you realize down deep that you are wrong but even if it costs all of us this beautiful, wonderful country, you don’t care.  Just so you get your way, like on the playground.
     
    If Sarah and Barack were to take a test on American History, she would win hands down.  I so hope the majority of the people still have enough good sense to put her in the White House.  Four more years of Obama and we are done.
     
    By the way, do you still think about the 57 states?

  • JRNASH

    Why is it that liberals who write comments on the Internet always sound like little boys on the playground who are trying to say something that will shock everybody.  I think that is why you go to the dirty language so quickly.  You never attack Sarah Palin on the issues because you would lose the debate and you know it.  It seems to most conservatives that I know that people like you realize down deep that you are wrong but even if it costs all of us this beautiful, wonderful country, you don’t care.  Just so you get your way, like on the playground.
     
    If Sarah and Barack were to take a test on American History, she would win hands down.  I so hope the majority of the people still have enough good sense to put her in the White House.  Four more years of Obama and we are done.
     
    By the way, do you still think about the 57 states?

  • http://twitter.com/blindrighteye dontactthemaggot

    when revere was detained by the british he conflated the numbers and strength of the colonial militia also he didnt want to draw attention to himself so there was no ringing of bells or warning shots from revere, she was caught guard and effed up like ALOT of other politicians the ridiculous pretzel logic does her supporters a disservice stop making excuses for her just admit she botched an answer , SHE IS HUMAN

    • Anonymous

      You lose so go tell somebody that cares.

  • http://twitter.com/blindrighteye dontactthemaggot

    when revere was detained by the british he conflated the numbers and strength of the colonial militia also he didnt want to draw attention to himself so there was no ringing of bells or warning shots from revere, she was caught guard and effed up like ALOT of other politicians the ridiculous pretzel logic does her supporters a disservice stop making excuses for her just admit she botched an answer , SHE IS HUMAN

  • http://twitter.com/blindrighteye dontactthemaggot

    when revere was detained by the british he conflated the numbers and strength of the colonial militia also he didnt want to draw attention to himself so there was no ringing of bells or warning shots from revere, she was caught guard and effed up like ALOT of other politicians the ridiculous pretzel logic does her supporters a disservice stop making excuses for her just admit she botched an answer , SHE IS HUMAN

  • Anonymous

    The definition of “quibbling” is arguing over MINOR issues in a statement, and there was/is nothing “minor” in Ms. Palin’s asinine rendition of American history regarding the fateful “midnight ride” of Paul Revere.  Never mind, for a moment, that she is a former state governor or even a potential U.S. Presidential candidate; her “explanation” of the meaning and details of the ride are simply pathetic.  That said, those who would (including Sarah herself) even *try* have us believe otherwise are even worse; far more cynical, foolish, and arrogantly defiant than any U.S. citizen should be.  God help us.

    • Anonymous

      You lose so get lost.  Tell it to somebody that cares.

  • Anonymous

    The definition of “quibbling” is arguing over MINOR issues in a statement, and there was/is nothing “minor” in Ms. Palin’s asinine rendition of American history regarding the fateful “midnight ride” of Paul Revere.  Never mind, for a moment, that she is a former state governor or even a potential U.S. Presidential candidate; her “explanation” of the meaning and details of the ride are simply pathetic.  That said, those who would (including Sarah herself) even *try* have us believe otherwise are even worse; far more cynical, foolish, and arrogantly defiant than any U.S. citizen should be.  God help us.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QKLPUWK6UHJPU4QR6HVBBAXYZA e k

    At first I thought Palin was right when I read this article. But after reading some of the points and counterpoints on this board (in spite of the heavy censoring the Palin fans of posts that they don’t like), I changed my mind and I don’t think Palin knew what she was talking about. She threw out a bunch of Revere references but she didn’t truly understand what happened in that historic moment. It’s sort of like those folks who didn’t know who Osama Bin Laden was and barely knew what happened in 9/11. They knew planes were involved but that doesn’t mean they had a true grasp of what happened and why and who.

    Conclusion, this article is grasping at straws. Oh and you Palin fans can go whine all about it but it’s all over the media how stupid she is and there’s nothing you can do to change that. Suck it.

    • Anonymous

      You lose so get lost.

  • http://www.facebook.com/RedneckWorld Ol’ Reb

    Isn’t it astounding that there are so many Americans who keep up with American Idol, celebrity trivia and sports stats, who can sing along with any Top 40 song on the radio, and yet could not answer an American history question correctly if their lives depended on it.  Yet, these same “intelligent, educated” Americans do not hesitate to rise to any opportunity to call Sarah Palin “stupid.”
    It seems that, for a large percentage of Americans, it has become increasingly easy – and convenient – to find even a non-existent mote in the eye of another, despite the veritable log jam in their own vision.
    And, God help us all, these people vote.

    • Anonymous

      I guess you think the most important part of P Revere’s ride was to warn the british, not the colonialists.  Where was that part of the explanation of that most famous night in her original photo op?  I still say if she had the opportunity to explain the colonial boston harbor event, there would be no tea party in the US today.  It would be housed in england.  Just what the movement here would be called i don’t know.  Maybe you can think of a good name

      • Anonymous

        You lose so get lost.

        • Anonymous

          Same for your idol.  I wish she would so this country could heal.  You want to vote conservative, vote for a true conservative human being, not a monkey seeking bananas

    • Anonymous

      I guess you think the most important part of P Revere’s ride was to warn the british, not the colonialists.  Where was that part of the explanation of that most famous night in her original photo op?  I still say if she had the opportunity to explain the colonial boston harbor event, there would be no tea party in the US today.  It would be housed in england.  Just what the movement here would be called i don’t know.  Maybe you can think of a good name

  • Anonymous

    In England a few days ago, Obama signed a guest book and put the date as 24 May 2008. I never saw anything about it in the leftist news organizations, and it was as nothing had happened.

    I wonder how many liberals/leftists/democrats even knew that that happened. Here it is:

    http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2011/05/president_obama_has_no_idea_wh.html

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QKLPUWK6UHJPU4QR6HVBBAXYZA e k

       Idiocy. Sure it’s stupid to get dates mixed up but it’s a far easier mistake to make and most common. But to get historic events wrong? That takes far greater stupidity. But you folks won’t ever understand this.

      • Anonymous

        But, can you imagine if Bush/Palin/Paul/Romney, et al, had done that? I’m pointing out leftist media hypocrisy.

        THREE years! Just where does the time go?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QKLPUWK6UHJPU4QR6HVBBAXYZA e k

    This excuse you Palin zombies are making up for Palin is ridiculous. It’s like saying 9/11 was just a bunch of muslims going for an airplane ride. While that’s true, an intelligent person who knows history would not describe it that way, leaving out the crucial facts and details important to the event. The fact that Palin describes Revere as warning the British instead of warning the Colonists reveals her stupidity even if she got one detail correct.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KI5FINKBHAQZRCWYIXDJJH6KFQ aCiD

    Really people. Why do you give a person, who really does not know her knee from her elbow, credit for making a stupid mistake.

    You back her up only after some history prof comes up with an obscure piece of information, that I know the vast majority of Americans don’t know.

    Really an idiot is an idiot until another idiot agrees with them. Then they are a bunch of idiots. You know what they call a bunch of idiots – Conservative Republicans or better yet reactionaries. I know you don’t know the definition so look it up.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KI5FINKBHAQZRCWYIXDJJH6KFQ aCiD

    Really people. Why do you give a person, who really does not know her knee from her elbow, credit for making a stupid mistake.

    You back her up only after some history prof comes up with an obscure piece of information, that I know the vast majority of Americans don’t know.

    Really an idiot is an idiot until another idiot agrees with them. Then they are a bunch of idiots. You know what they call a bunch of idiots – Conservative Republicans or better yet reactionaries. I know you don’t know the definition so look it up.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KI5FINKBHAQZRCWYIXDJJH6KFQ aCiD

    Really people. Why do you give a person, who really does not know her knee from her elbow, credit for making a stupid mistake.

    You back her up only after some history prof comes up with an obscure piece of information, that I know the vast majority of Americans don’t know.

    Really an idiot is an idiot until another idiot agrees with them. Then they are a bunch of idiots. You know what they call a bunch of idiots – Conservative Republicans or better yet reactionaries. I know you don’t know the definition so look it up.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KI5FINKBHAQZRCWYIXDJJH6KFQ aCiD

    Oh and one other piece of historical information those same British also burned your White House. Don’t forget you lost the war of 1812.

    They spanked your butts and took your stuff. Read it and weep.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KI5FINKBHAQZRCWYIXDJJH6KFQ aCiD

    Oh and one other piece of historical information those same British also burned your White House. Don’t forget you lost the war of 1812.

    They spanked your butts and took your stuff. Read it and weep.

  • Anonymous

    I can’t understand why everyone is trying to support or condemn Palin over the Paul Revere issue? When the real issue that’s never been answered is why she quit in the middle of her Governor’s term?
    No matter how good or bad a candidate she might be. Do we want a quitter in the White House? Not ME! She should stick to Fox news where she can quit at anytime and not leave anyone sorry. DJ 

Open Thread

Our Sarah

Governor Palin's Tweets