Erick Erickson | The problem with Rubio’s plan

You’d be surprised how long it has taken to say this.  I’ve let multiple friends vet the various drafts of posts I’ve written on this and they all wind up arguing with each other over the details.  Is it amnesty or isn’t it?  Should we give a path to citizenship or not?  We are getting in the weeds when the basics will do.

I think this plan is warmed over McCain-Kennedy and will do nothing to solve the problem.  I say this as someone to the left of much of the readership here at RedState and the conservative base.

The GOP was smart to put Marco Rubio as the face of the plan because many of us like him personally, support him still, and consequently don’t want to seem critical.

But the plan makes the actual problem of immigration more difficult to solve.

More.



(18853 Posts)