Categorized | Opinion

Whitney Pitcher: Will ACES Be Discarded?

Great piece by Whitney Pitcher today, outlining the current debate in Alaska to overturn one of Governor Palin’s greatest achievements in office, ACES (Alaska’s Clear and Equitable Share):

During her CPAC speech last Saturday, Governor Palin included some Alaskan constitutional populism (emphasis added):

If Mrs. Thatcher were with us here today, she would remind us that there is a big difference between being pro-business and being pro-free market. On this there can be no mistake where conservatives stand. It’s time for “We the People” to break up the cronyism and put a stake through the heart of "too big to fail" once and for all.

That includes these resource-rich states like Alaska, my home state. Read your constitution, Alaskans. Realize that the natural resources that God has created for man’s use – they’re not owned by the big multinational conglomerates and the monopolies. They’re owned by the people. They don’t own them, so don’t let them own you. You have a right to those resources to be developed for our use.

Governor Palin rightfully notes two important issues in particular–1) the Alaskan constitution’s charge that development of resources for the good of the people 2) the warning that the people (and politicians) of Alaska  not allow themselves to be owned by the oil companies.

The Alaskan constitution notes that the state’s natural resources belong to the people and are to developed for their maximum benefit :

 The legislature shall provide for the utilization, development, and conservation of all natural resources belonging to the State, including land and waters, for the maximum benefit of its people.

Governor Palin’s point is especially salient and timely when it comes to Alaska’s natural resources. On Wednesday night, the Alaska state senate passed a bill that if passed in the House and signed by Governor Parnell would overhaul the oil tax reform plan, ACES, that Governor Palin signed into law in 2007. Unlike Governor Palin’s ACES, however, this bill was not discussed in a transparent and comprehensive manner:

 The newest version of the oil tax bill was introduced Thursday. In the hours before it passed there no public testimony. There was no testimony from Alaska’s independent oil explorers. The only industry testimony came from Alaska’s Big Three oil producers, which had been invited to testify.

"It was sort of striking that the oil industry gets a chance for public comment and the rest of Alaskans don’t," Wielechowski said.

Many of the smaller independent players in Alaska’s oil patch are the beneficiaries of tax incentives aimed at new production from new fields, rather than the strategy pushed by Parnell and championed by legislative leaders of pumping oil, faster, from known fields.

Testimony from the Big Three acknowledged that the oil-tax changes proposed under SB 21 would make Alaska a more competitive tax environment. But they would not promise new production.

One of the positives of ACES is that smaller, independent oil companies have been able to develop in Alaska. In fact, the number of oil tax returns filed with Alaska has increased 383% since ACES was passed. Annual capital expenditures have nearly doubled since FY2007, meaning that producers are engaging in increased infrastructure development (i.e. more rigs) and the like. These expenditures are helping to lead to increased profits for even the major oil companies. For example, in 2012, 13% of Conoco Phillips’s oil and gas development occurred in Alaska, but Alaska contributed to 34% of their income. Additionally, according to Alaska’s own labor statistics, oil and gas jobs increased more than 15% between 2007 and 2012.

So, why is there a push for reforming ACES? Because of the very thing that Governor Palin warned against in her CPAC speech–being owned by the oil companies. In theory, the Senate bill is better for the oil companies because it flattens ACES’s tax rate and provides incentives for new oil. This sounds pro-business, right? That’s what Governor Palin warned about in her CPAC speech as well. There’s a difference between the invisible hand of the free market and the hand-in-hand "pro business" relationship between business and government. This "hand-in-hand" relationship is the very type of relationship that was the impetus for ACES being passed in the first place, as the Murkowski administration prior to Palin’s administration was shrouded in corruption due to the pay-to-play deals between the oil companies and lawmakers. Governor Parnell has not had that kind of relationship in his dealings, but he has had a revolving door relationship between the oil industry and politics. As I wrote nearly two years ago:

In the early and mid 1990s, Parnell served in the Alaska House of Representatives and Senate. Following his time in the Senate, Parnell became director of government relations for ConoccoPhillips. He then went to work for Governor Murkowski as the director state division of oil and gas from 2003 to 2005. During part of this period time, Governor Palin had served as an oil and gas commissioner until she encountered unethical behavior from another commissioner and Alaska GOP chair,Randy Ruedrich, and she resigned and lodged a complaint against Ruedrich. Prior to running for Lt. Governor in 2006, Parnell worked at Patton Boggs, a law firm that represented ConocoPhillips and ExxonMobil in the Exxon Valdex oil spill case.

Although the bill was passed in the Senate, it was proposed at the request of Governor Parnell. He found 11 allies in the Senate, and the bill passed 11-9. One Senator, Peter Micciche, who is also employed as a ConocoPhillips natural gas plant supervisor,  paid lip service support to ACES, indicating he would reject Governor Parnell’s proposal. However, Micciche ended up voting for the modified Senate bill that Governor Parnell applauded.

Please go here to read the entire piece.

Tags: , , , , ,

Comment Policy: The Editors reserve the right to delete any comments which in their sole discretion are deemed false or misleading, profane, pornographic, defamatory, harassment, name calling, libelous, threatening, or otherwise inappropriate. Additionally, the Editors reserve the right to ban any registered poster who, in their sole discretion, violates the terms of use. Do not post any information about yourself reasonably construed as private or confidential. Conservatives4Palin and its contributors are not liable if users allow others to contact them offsite.

  • alien4palin

    Alaska, hold your representatives feet to the fire and demand accountability.

  • RebinTexas

    Dang Parnell – he’s been working to do this for some time. I pray the People of Alaska are able to put a stop to this……for their sake. Thanks for the info Whitney. Much appreciated.

  • jester2939

    Come on Alaskans, wake up!! Demand transparency and honesty from your government.

  • angeleno

    Parnell was supposed to be in sync with Sarah…now he’s trying to sink her No. 1 achievement? Shows the need for Sarah to get back into Alaskan politics. Her state needs her, this would reveal the truth about her governorship, it would position her to run for the U.S. Senate. She really should, whether or not she wants to run for president which I accept she may not. She’d be working for her home state as well as for all the USA, but most important it would gives her a base of authority and power from which to help Alaska and America. I agree you don’t need an office to have a voice or effect change, BUT an office like U.S. Senator certainly magnifies the strength and authority of your efforts.

  • friskyness

    Alaskans seemed so smart, but they let the media attack Palin, they re-elected Murkowski ,and they let Parnell destroy ACES! So dissappointed in Alaskans.

  • John_Frank

    Excellent article by Whitney Pitcher.

    Thank you Stacey for bringing this article to people’s attention.

  • Lisa Graas

    ACES needs to be preserved. By the way, ACES is very Catholic. If there is a Catholic contributor on C4P, please email me at lisagraas ‘at’ yahoo ‘dot’ com. I’d like to talk with you about this. Thanks.

    • sno_warrior

      ??? What does being ‘very catholic’ mean and what difference does it make?????

    • Sinforosa87

      Lisa is reaching out. We need a united front folks. Inclusion please.

  • joseph agibinik

    As an Alaskan, after reading your posts, all I can say is dang. Call me stupid, I don’t understand this bill. We raise taxes, the oil companies don’t drill. We lower taxes, the oil companies don’t drill. All of you are blaming us for what democrates, unions, native corporations, and rino republicans are doing to us? This is the perfect example of rino republicans working with democrates, unions, and native corporations. They are the same. I have read about this bill, I have read c4p stories on it, I have read about it in the Anchorage Daily News…..I have heard stories about it on the local radio stations. I have looked it up on the internet. I have tried. I still do not understand. Call me dumb. I don’t know why Parnell is attacking ACES. I don’t know why all of you think this is Alaskan’s fault. We, in Alaska, just like the United States of America, have been at war with democrates. Alaska Natives vote democrate. Unions vote democrate. Democrates vote democrate. All three of these groups voted for Murkowski for senate. We tried getting rid of her. Write-in? Democrates voted FOR murkykowski. All of you know who won president. Why? I believe it is the same. Democrates helped elect romney who was unelectible. Rino republicans elected romney who was unelectible. Romneycare, anyone? I am mad. I am offended by some of your posts here. I have to stop…..I was raised "if you have nothing nice to say, don’t say anything at all." You people who blame Alaskans should be ashamed of yourself. Alaskans elected Sarah Palin to office. I have to stop.


    If I fine gold in my stream do I have to divide it with my neighbors?

  • John_Frank

    People may also find the following analysis by Barbara Haney of value:

    Palin’s Geopolitical Prowess, Empowerment, and ACES Reform

    Note the discussion under the post between Ms. Haney and Ms. Pitcher.

  • petedoc810

    I think Sarah should make her intentions known that she will run against Parnell when he is up for re-election. Maybe this will push him into the race for Senator. Governor of Alaska means only one person — Sarah Palin.

Open Thread

Governor Palin’s Tweets